sunvale1 wrote: Am I being to picky in looking at a prospective boat?
Peter

Well...
Like everything, it depends. How old are the boats that you're looking at? Age is a factor. You can also have a boat that's been very well maintained but, as an owner starts to slow down or back out of boating, it doesn't get kept quite as well. The marine environment is a tough one! You'd need to determine if it's issues are structural or cosmetic, isolated or widespread. And then factor in your time and $$ to get it where you want.
I joke with a friend of mine - All boats of a particular brand and vintage cost exactly the same - it's just a case of when you spend the money! (Meaning of course that a "cheap" boat will require a lot more work, usually, than a pricier one)
So look for the boat you want with solid "bones", good hull, mechanicals, etc. and determine if the decks and such are in your comfort range.
Good luck!